> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://goodoil.news/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Rape Myths and Two Tier Justice
- URL: https://goodoil.news/rape-myths-and-two-tier-justice/
- Published: 2026-11-20T00:30:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-20T00:29:59.000Z
- Description: The thin end of a very large wedge, designed to destroy any semblance of real justice.
- Author: Reproduced with permission
- Tags: UK Politics, Justice System

[**Steven Barnes**](https://www.freespeechbacklash.com/article/rape-myths-and-two-tier-justice?ref=goodoil.news)  
*FSB*

Justice Secretary Alex Norris’s letter to the Bar Standards Board, demanding stronger professional standards to stop barristers “relying on rape myths” in sexual-offence trials, is a politicised intervention that treats the criminal courtroom as an extension of government messaging. The minister is careful to say that any new rules would be set by the regulator rather than imposed by him, but that caveat is window-dressing. Everyone who has watched British institutions operate for the last decade knows how these things work. When the state signals what it wants, the ‘independent’ regulator finds a way to deliver it. The Bar Standards Board has already set up an expert reference group on the subject. The outcome is predictable.

The first and most basic problem is definitional. What, precisely, is a “rape myth”? The phrase is treated as if it were a settled category of prohibited speech, yet it is elastic enough to cover almost any defence argument that does not accept the complainant’s account at face value. In the Russell Brand trial the defence is said to have pointed out that the women did not scream, kick or flee. Those observations are now labelled myths. But they are also ordinary questions about demeanour, consistency and the surrounding circumstances. Once such questions become professionally dangerous, counsel is no longer free to test the evidence. The advocate who asks them risks disciplinary action; the advocate who declines to ask them leaves the client half-defended. That is not a technical adjustment to professional standards. It is a shift in the burden of proof dressed up as ethical progress.

This fits a wider pattern. Britain already operates a two-tier justice system in which certain groups receive markedly more favourable treatment than others. The establishment has little patience for right-wing patriots, working-class protesters or anyone else who challenges the official consensus. The same system is increasingly arranged to treat women who allege rape as a protected class, whose claims must be handled with special solicitude, while men defending those allegations are treated as presumptively suspect. The Norris letter adds another formal layer to that imbalance. If the regulator duly issues rules that restrict the range of permissible defence arguments, the practical effect will be that complainants face fewer awkward questions and defendants face greater difficulty in mounting a full defence. Equality before the law is not advanced by loading the dice in one direction.

The Russell Brand case illustrates the dangers with particular clarity. The allegations concerned events from 15 to 20 years earlier. Multiple complainants came forward after media investigations, producing the familiar scatter-gun effect: throw enough accusations and some will stick. Brand had by then become a vocal critic of prevailing cultural and political orthodoxies. That fact is not strictly legally relevant, but it is politically and culturally relevant. High-profile men who turn against the approved narrative have discovered that the past can be reopened with remarkable ease and that the media will amplify every allegation while largely ignoring the defence. In such an atmosphere the defendant already starts at a disadvantage. If his counsel is then told that certain lines of cross-examination or closing argument risk professional ruin, the disadvantage becomes structural. Fair trial rights are not abstract. They require counsel who can put the case without looking over their shoulder at a regulator that has been steered by the justice secretary.

None of this denies that rape is a serious crime or that some long-standing assumptions about sexual violence have been wrong. But it means recognising that the criminal process exists to determine specific allegations against specific individuals, not to educate the public or affirm social values. When ministers instruct regulators to police the language and tactics of defence barristers, they are converting the courtroom into a theatre of approved attitudes. This, it is evident, is exactly the intention, i.e., thinner justice for those the system is already inclined to dislike.

The stakes are high. Once the principle is established that certain arguments are professionally off-limits because they perpetuate “myths,” the list of forbidden topics will expand. Today it is questions about resistance or delayed reporting. Tomorrow it may be questions about previous sexual history, intoxication, or inconsistencies that cut against the preferred narrative. Each restriction will be justified by the same language of victim protection and social progress. Each will further tilt the process against the accused. Men in Brand’s position – public, contested, and politically inconvenient – will feel the effect first. Ordinary defendants will feel it next.

And once established, the principle is likely to spread to non-rape trials, to hate crime trials, where counsel for the defence will be cautioned not to perpetuate ‘myths’ about certain groups being more disposed to violence or terrorism. The thin end of a very large wedge, designed to destroy any semblance of real justice. 

A justice system that cannot tolerate robust defence advocacy is not protecting victims: it is protecting a political idea. Norris’s letter, and the regulatory response that will almost certainly follow, should be recognised for what it is: another step in the politicisation of criminal justice, taken under the cover of professional standards.

This article was originally published by the [Free Speech Backlash](https://www.freespeechbacklash.com/article/rape-myths-and-two-tier-justice?ref=goodoil.news).