> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://goodoil.news/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Great US Car Rental EV Debacle
- URL: https://goodoil.news/the-great-us-car-rental-ev-debacle/
- Published: 2026-11-20T01:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-20T01:00:00.000Z
- Description: Car rental lots in the US are awash with EVs, and the reason is simple, says Guy de la Bédoyère: most renters won’t touch them, because they’re not insane. Whatever you do, don’t let the agent talk you into taking one.
- Author: Reproduced with permission
- Tags: Travel, Business, Energy

[**Guy de la Bédoyère**](https://dailysceptic.org/2026/11/17/the-great-us-car-rental-ev-debacle/?ref=goodoil.news)  
*Guy de la Bédoyère is a historian and writer with numerous books to his credit.*

A few days ago, we arrived in Texas at Dallas-Fort Worth Airport. I had a prepaid Avis petrol rental car booked, so off we trotted to the rental car centre. We travel a great deal in the United States, and I have already driven 8,000 miles this year over two journeys in the Western states as far apart as North Dakota and New Mexico. We had a petrol Mazda for one trip and a Toyota Camry hybrid for the second.

How many EV chargers do you think I spotted on those trips? I cannot recall a single one.

At the rental car lot, I was told to go to the preferred counter, since I joined that programme last year. Luckily, I got there when I did because 10 minutes after I arrived there was a queue of eight more renters, four times as many as at the regular counter.

**We only have EVs**

I was more than faintly alarmed when the agent told me, “we only have minivans and EVs”. What? I refused either. I also said there was no chance I would rent an EV. I held out. A lot of pointless fiddling about with computers ensued. I was offered an SUV but by the time my card had gone through the SUV had been taken by a renter at the regular desk.

The agent tried to push an EV on me again. I said there was utterly no way under the sun I was embarking on a US road trip in an EV. After a further 10 minutes of this, as if by magic, a nearly new sleek black Toyota Camry hybrid (see picture) became available, so we took it. As this was being finally sorted out, I watched a Chinese visitor (with excellent English) being fast-talked into taking an EV. The agent told him proudly, “you’ll get at least 250–300 miles per charge”.

“Where can I charge it?” he asked wanly but I could see him caving. I nearly intervened but thought that would enrage the Avis staff, so I held off.

When we got to our Camry it was plain it had been there all the time. Since we undertake these road trips regularly, I began to worry that on future visits I might find myself well and truly done up like a kipper.

**Stand fast**

I started doing some research. The reason the lot was awash with EVs is because most renters won’t touch them. The reason for this is that they are not insane or mugs. It seems the agents are told to try and push EVs on renters in a desperate attempt to shift them off the lot. So, they tell porky pies about the availability of other cars but keep a cohort of proper vehicles back for people like me who stand fast and insist they’re not touching an EV.

It’s fatal to book a ‘manager’s special’. You might as well shoot yourself. And don’t accept an ‘upgrade’ either (unless it’s to a better petrol car).

It seems the Avis Budget Group has faced an EV fiasco. *Auto Rental New*s has a story from 2025 about how ‘[Avis Budget Group Reports Near $1 Billion Loss Tied To 2025 EV Fleet Write-Down](https://www.autorentalnews.com/news/avis-budget-group-reports-near-1-billion-loss-tied-to-2025-ev-fleet-write-down?ref=goodoil.news)’.

Here’s what happened to one renter who was [suckered into taking an EV](https://www.reddit.com/r/travel/comments/1u33q7o/avis%5Fcar%5Frental%5Fsubstituted%5Fus%5Fwith%5Fan%5Fev%5Fand/?ref=goodoil.news):

> **Avis car rental substituted us with an EV and this quite possibly was the biggest travel mistake I’ve ever made**  
>  
> Hey all, I will first admit that I made the bonehead mistake of accepting an electric vehicle as a rental substitute, having no knowledge of EV or the charging infrastructure of our destination. This is a huge mistake on my part, but now I’m looking for solutions.  
>  
> We are traveling from Springfield, MO to Big Bend, Texas. We rented from Avis a Nissan Altima, but instead they only had a 2024 Kia Nero EV available. I accepted, oblivious to the turmoil and anxiety this decision would have on our trip.  
>  
> So far, we’ve made it 2.5 hours out of the entire 13 hour drive. We’ve only been able to find slow charging stations (we did not know there was a difference in charging stations, let alone the time difference).  
>  
> The best we’ve found is a 50kW charging station, but I believe this will still take us two hours to get to a full charge. We are only taking this trip for the two days, and we’re supposed to drive back the entirety of the last day so we can make it back home for work on Monday.  
>  
> With just the additional charging time, we’re looking at roughly another 15 hours of just charging, which quite honestly doesn’t seem feasible for such a short duration of a trip.  
>  
> Has anyone had any luck with swapping EV rentals for gas with Avis? Are we missing something here? We’ve found EVGos but none of the power cords go to our EV.  
>  
> We’re pretty stuck right now, and starting to lose hope on this trip overall.

The fact is that EVs have proved to be a rental car market disaster. For a start, it takes a rental car company as little as 15 minutes to turn round a petrol car and rent it out again. An EV can take several hours to recharge before they start earning again, and even then rental EVs can be sent out with as little as a 70 per cent charge. They also cost far more to repair and get through tyres and brake pads more quickly.

**Plug and pray**

If you booked a petrol car, switching to an EV would entail different Ts and Cs and new contract. Wised-up renters know they are [not legally obliged to accept an EV](https://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherelliott/2025/11/08/no-plug-no-play-the-real-reason-the-rental-ev-revolution-is-stalling/?ref=goodoil.news), according to *Forbes*, which goes on: 

> “Overall, EV rental demand remains low today,” says Chris Haffenreffer, Vice President of Strategy at Enterprise Mobility.  
>  
> This creates a stalemate. Low demand and the recent removal of government credits means fewer EVs in rental fleets. Fewer EVs mean less commercial pressure to improve public charging. And that poor infrastructure keeps demand stuck at the bottom.  
>  
> “For many of our renters, convenience is critical,” Haffenreffer explains. “Saving a few bucks on fuel likely doesn’t outweigh the inconvenience and anxiety that often comes with the charging experience – particularly for a new EV driver.”  
>  
> Research from JD Power paints a grim picture of public charging. The most common reason for a failed charging visit – affecting 60 per cent of attempts – is the charger simply being out of service.  
>  
> JD Power found that EV drivers in Seattle reported a 25 per cent failure rate on charging attempts; Los Angeles was 24 per cent. For a tourist on a tight schedule, those odds are unacceptable. Add in wait times – which JD Power found at 18 per cent of charging attempts in San Francisco – and the EV ‘upgrade’ looks more like a downgrade.  
>  
> The current EV reality is ‘plug-and-pray’.  
>  
> Travellers are not obligated to accept an EV if it doesn’t fit their needs. Rental agents may present EVs as upgrades, but a polite decline is fine. A simple, ‘I’d prefer a gas or better yet hybrid vehicle for this trip’, will do.

Or will it? I had to be pretty firm at the Avis desk in Dallas-Forth Worth. Now, I know this is about my experience in the United States. And I am well aware of the distances here (I have already driven 1,000 miles in six days). But my experience still shows what’s coming in Britain.

According to [Roadgenius](https://roadgenius.com/cars/rental/ev-statistics-usa/?ref=goodoil.news), most US business renters won’t touch EVs, probably because they don’t want to lose their jobs while waiting for a charge:

![](https://dailysceptic.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/image-88.png)

**EV means Endless Vexation**

The fact is that EVs have been pushed on an unsuspecting public far too quickly and way ahead of an infrastructure change that will take decades, and untold quantities of copper cabling and generating capacity, to create.

Worse, the only conceivable way an EV could emulate the driving experience of a petrol car would be if you could drive into an installation and have the flat battery swapped over for a fully charged one in five minutes (you can in fact do that with small motorcycles in the Far East). But instead, we are faced with a tidal wave of inconvenience in the form of searching for a charger, finding a compatible one, finding one that isn’t broken, and finding one that isn’t being used. And all that on top of waiting for an hour or more to get the wretched vehicle charged.

Imagine being in a strange country as well. Car rental probably epitomises the problems with EVs for owners, renters and rental companies. Unless you only plan to pootle around for a couple of days in a city, the only possibility is a grossly worse experience than having an ICE or hybrid car. Your first job is researching the local EV charging infrastructure and connecter compatibility before even daring to drive the car.

What then will pushing EVs on the public do to the UK rental car market?

No surprise then that NoBirds, a well-known Australian car rental firm which I use every year too, sticks to petrol and hybrids. Imagine looking for a charger in a place called Wallaboomerangoo, ‘Are there any EV chargers here?’ ‘Funny question. You’ll be lucky, mate’.

Personally, I couldn’t care less if the price of fuel ends up being five times as much as the electricity for a charge, whether in the US or anywhere else.

I’m sticking with a petrol or hybrid rental car for the foreseeable. Back home, my 1990 Volvo 740 16v dohc estate (passed its 33rd MoT three weeks ago, and only ever failed once) is staying in my garage. Cost me £2,999 in 2001\. Four more years and it goes tax and Ulez free. No brainer.

But if the US rental car companies don’t sort themselves out, that’ll be the end of our road trips. With any luck, after having their fingers burned, they’ll wind back their EV inventories, and I won’t have to argue the toss again when we pull into Denver next June. Canada seems to be ahead of the game, where ‘[Travellers Looking for EVs Won’t Find Them at Car Rental Companies](https://www.theenergymix.com/travellers-looking-for-evs-wont-find-them-at-car-rental-companies/?ref=goodoil.news)’, according to the *Energy Mix*.

I don’t want to end up in Dead Battery City, New Mexico, or Shattered Dreams, Texas, looking for an EV charger in among the abandoned main street lots with derelict restaurants, ruined motels and only the odd static home among the tumbleweed and cans in the gutter. Even the most wretched of such places usually has a functioning gas station.

This article was originally published by [the Daily Sceptic](https://dailysceptic.org/2026/11/17/the-great-us-car-rental-ev-debacle/?ref=goodoil.news).