> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://goodoil.news/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# They Who Shall Not Be Named
- URL: https://goodoil.news/they-who-shall-not-be-named/
- Published: 2026-11-19T01:30:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T01:29:59.000Z
- Description: Ben Carroll refuses to invoke the ghosts of his predecessors.
- Author: Lushington Brady
- Tags: AUS Politics

There were Banquo’s ghosts aplenty at the Victorian leaders’ debate this week. Only, in an inversion of the Scottish Play, everyone can see and, more importantly, name them: everyone but the man playing the role of Macbeth in this little drama.

In an excruciating exchange, Labor Premier **Ben Carroll** desperately avoided even saying the names of his predecessors, **Dan Andrews** and **Jacinta Allan**.

> [Premier Ben Carroll](https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/jess-wilson-takes-convincing-win-as-victoria-premier-ben-carroll-suffers-name-game-gaffe/news-story/9f7c63e1ac57805324078d5e583fc386?ref=goodoil.news) refused to name Daniel Andrews or Jacinta Allan when challenged over their legacy in the only debate of the Victorian election campaign, drawing laughter and applause from undecided voters when Liberal leader **Jess Wilson** took up his challenge to name **Jeff Kennett**.

No, no, no, insisted Carroll afterward. He mentioned them once, but he thinks he got away with it.

> [Ben Carroll insists](https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/politics-latest-penny-wong-unveils-fresh-round-of-sanctions-on-israeli-settlers/live-coverage/0c20c47a397d193981dd6def9c061105?ref=goodoil.news) he was about to name Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan in Tuesday night’s election debate, but got “cut off” before he could do so.  
>  
> Mr Carroll, speaking at a press conference on Wednesday, said: “I actually was saying, did say Bracks, Brumby, Dan and Jacinta … and I couldn’t finish it, and I said they all stand these former premiers as fighting for working people.”

Eleven days out from the November 28 election, and hours before early voting began, the News24 People’s Forum of roughly 100 undecided voters turned what was meant to be a leaders’ debate into something closer to an autopsy. The latest Newspoll already points to a heavy Labor defeat. This night did nothing to reverse the direction of travel.

The sharpest exchange came when moderator **Kieran Gilbert** asked why Carroll invoked former Labor premiers **Steve Bracks** and **John Brumby** while passing over Andrews and Allan. This gave Wilson the dream opening to skewer the premier.

> “He’s not Voldemort … the question was about Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan. I think by your very answer you have demonstrated that you are ashamed of their legacies here in Victoria, you can’t even say their names,” Ms Wilson said.  
>  
> “I can say their names, like you can say Jeff Kennett’s name,” Mr Carroll said.  
>  
> “Jeff Kennett,” Ms Wilson replied, sparking laughter and applause.

Carroll finds himself hobbled by the concrete boots of the past: state debt, the pandemic response, the Suburban Rail Loop, crime and the $15 billion question mark hanging over alleged Big Build corruption. Technically solid in patches, the facts were heavily against him. He completely struggled with the Andrews name. Wilson had earlier pressed him on why he failed to speak up during his years in cabinet.

The first question from the floor, from a voter named Michael, asked how Carroll would bring down debt and put the economy on a sustainable footing. The premier claimed Labor was reducing debt and would avoid measures that would “crash the economy”. Wilson reiterated the coalition’s pledge of a cash surplus by 2032–33 and noted the interest bill, more than $1 million an hour, crowding out schools, hospitals and police.

They clashed over the Suburban Rail Loop. Carroll insisted Victoria needed an orbital rail line and that he had found $2 billion in savings by stripping out “the bells and whistles”. Wilson said a coalition government would pause and review the project, and challenged him to disclose which contracts had been signed and how much taxpayers were already committed to spending. Carroll was looking for a knockout and hit the mat instead. It is the curse of being a new premier at the fag end of a 12-year government.

The decision to put four leaders on stage gave One Nation’s **Warren Pickering** the oxygen his campaign needed. He was strong, across the detail and spoke directly to struggling voters. The Greens’ **Ellen Sandell** defaulted to peak inner-city politicking on the Middle East and indigenous treaty. Previously something of a political myth, she now has a name. Even if you do not agree with her views, they are at least known.

The room gave the night to Wilson, which was more than fair enough. With early voting already open, Carroll’s mission has become one of sandbagging safe Labor seats. The ghosts of Andrews and Allan still crowd the stage. Everyone else can name them. Only Macbeth cannot.

---

💡

****If you enjoyed this article please share it using the share buttons at the top or bottom of the article.**