> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://goodoil.news/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Why Can’t Animals Talk like Us?
- URL: https://goodoil.news/why-cant-animals-talk-like-us/
- Published: 2026-11-21T20:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-21T19:59:59.000Z
- Description: Even apes have the basic equipment, but only humans talk.
- Author: Lushington Brady
- Tags: Science

“If I could talk to the animals,” *Doctor Doolittle* (**Rex Harrison**) sang in the 1967 film of the same name, “and they could talk to me”. Fantasy author **Raymond E Feist** took a different take: one of his characters can talk to animals, but relates that most of what they have to say is exceedingly mundane.

But, as we all know, animals cannot talk to us, which begs the question: *why not?* It was long thought it was just a matter of physiology, but the famous sign-language apes have in fact been mostly a bitter disappointment. Firstly, it has become plain that the researchers making the extraordinary claims were simply making a lot of it up. At best, seeing what they desperately wanted to see, while sign-language speakers saw only gibberish. Secondly, apes’ use of sign language is distressingly deficient: almost entirely limited to simple demands, well below the ability and curiosity of the average human toddler just learning to talk. ‘No ape has ever asked, *Why is the sky blue?*’ as one researcher puts it.

It turns out, though, that even some monkey species, from whom we evolutionarily split around 25 million years ago, have a vocal tract which can produce at least five clearly different vowel sounds.

> [\[Resarchers’\] models showed](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U9r6Rz%5FNwFI&ref=goodoil.news) a macaque’s vocal tract could produce at least five clearly different vowels. Their conclusion: monkeys have a speech-ready vocal tract, but not a speech-ready brain. So, anatomy alone can’t be the whole story.

Still, anatomy *is* important, and the fossil record shows when our anatomy began to change. A 60,000 year old Neanderthal skeleton from Israel show one extraordinary little bone: a small horseshoe-shaped throat bone called the hyoid. It anchors the tongue and supports the larynx. And fossil hyoids are extremely rare. This Neanderthal hyoid is almost identical in size and shape to ours. A 2013 study found that even its internal structure matches, suggesting it was used in similar ways.

A chimpanzee’s hyoid is very different to ours. So was the hyoid of an *Australopithecus* child from about 3.3 million years ago. But hyoids of early relatives of Neanderthal from about half a million years ago already look much like ours.

Then there is the matter of breath. Speaking needs fine control of the rib muscles so we can talk through one long exhalation. In 1999 **Ann MacLarnon** and **Gwen Hewitt** found that the spinal canal in the chest is wider in modern humans and Neanderthals than in other primates: perhaps room for the extra nerves that control breathing. A *Homo erectus* skeleton from 1.6 million years ago is normal ape-size, suggesting that such breath control arrived later.

Bones are only half the story. The other half is written in DNA. In the 1990s researchers studied the British KE family. About half its members across three generations struggled to coordinate the rapid mouth movements speech demands. In 2001 geneticists traced the problem to a single letter change in one gene, FOXP2\. Every affected family member carried it. FOXP2 makes a protein that switches other genes on and off, helping build brain circuits for learned movements. It was quickly dubbed “the language gene”.

Scientists now call that label misleading. Human FOXP2 differs from the chimpanzee version by just two amino acids. A 2002 study suggested these changes had spread through our ancestors within the last 200,000 years. Ancient DNA then altered the picture. In 2007 scientists recovered FOXP2 from Neanderthal bones in Spain. They carried the same two changes we do. The human version is older than the split between our lineages several hundred thousand years ago. A 2018 study of hundreds of genomes found no sign of a recent selective sweep at all.

> FOXP2 is one part of the machinery, not a switch that turned language on.

If bones and genes cannot settle it, behaviour might. Scientists split into two camps. One says language began with the hands. Apes are fluent gesturers, which is likely why sign language experiments succeeded at all. But the ‘vocabulary’ is limited to about 20 meanings, mostly demands of one kind or another, which is probably why the success of ape signing was so limited.

The other camp says it started with the voice. Vervet monkeys in Africa give different alarm calls for different predators. In classic 1980 experiments, researchers played these calls from hidden speakers. A leopard alarm sent the monkeys running into trees. An eagle alarm made them look up. A snake alarm made them look down.

Many researchers now suspect the answer lies in between. Our ancestors probably mixed gestures, faces and voices, just as we still talk with our hands today.

*When* it happened is the subject of just as much debate. The range of scientific difference is as much as 2 million or 200,000 years and as recent as 60,000 years. Don’t let anyone tell you science is settled.

Some of the best evidence for how language starts comes not from fossils but from children. Before the late 1970s most deaf people in Nicaragua stayed at home with little contact with each other. Then in 1977 a special education school opened in Managua. About 50 deaf students enrolled at first. By 1981 there were over 200\. No one taught them to sign, but as soon as they were together the children began building a shared system of gestures. It grew into a full language, Nicaraguan Sign Language.

> Given a community, kids don’t just learn language, they build it.

Babies show us something too. Typically between about six and 10 months, infants start canonical babbling, repeated syllables like “ba, ba, ba” and “ma, ma, ma”. Babbling is practice, tuning the mouth to the sounds of the language around them. In 1991 **Laura Ann Petitto** and **Paula Marentette** reported that deaf babies exposed to sign language babble with their hands in rhythmic syllable-like movements. Babbling seems to be about language itself, not just sound.

But the basic problem seems insurmountable: speech leaves almost no trace. Words do not fossilise and the tongue and larynx rot away. All we have are indirect clues.

What is clear is that by the time our species spread around the world, every group carried language with it.

> No human population has ever been found without one.

The problem, it often seems, is not why humans talk: it’s how to shut them up, now that they do.

---

💡

****If you enjoyed this article please share it using the share buttons at the top or bottom of the article.**