Skip to content

An Inadvertently Tragic Story of Decline

The sort of people that cannot tell Churchill from a mayor, or Elgar from a rapper, will not be able to tell Æthelstan from anyone else. Don’t be surprised if we end up with a statue of Sadiq Khan on the fourth plinth if they ever choose to make it permanent.

King Æthelstan (left) presenting a book to St Cuthbert (right). Credit: MS 183, f.1v at the Parker Library at Corpus Christi College, Cambridge

Laura Dodsworth
Writer, photographer, commentator.

“Britain is the country of Churchill and Sadiq Khan, Britain is the country of Elgar and Stormzy, Britain is the country of churches, mosques, football stands. Britain is a country where we stand together; different communities, but common values. We remember our greatest moment in this country, which was defeating fascism in the second world war. Different communities that come together. Our culture that’s intertwined. We can read Shakespeare and Zadie Smith. That’s what Britain is. I am so, so proud to be British, and all the things we’ve achieved and the way we live together and will continue to achieve. This is not just simply the greatest country on earth. People who look different come together.”

– Jeevun Sandher, MP, Politics Live, BBC Two, 12 November 2026

It would be a strange land indeed where Churchill and Khan were given equal standing, where Elgar and Stormzy share top musical billing.

Although I suspect most of the inhabitants of this land would not agree. The history books will speak for themselves in due course. For now, we must conclude that it is not our land, but the landscape of Jeevun Sandher’s mind which is a little strange.

Consider the comparison he invited, on BBC Politics Live. Sir Winston Churchill recognised the threat of Nazi Germany when others looked away, and led Great Britain to victory in the second world war. Sir Sadiq Khan is accused, time and again, of failing to deal with the knife crime crisis in London.

As First Lord of the Admiralty, Churchill oversaw vital naval modernisation. Khan rolled out ULEZ to Greater London.

Churchill saw the country through its darkest hour. Khan switched on the Eid lights in central London.

Where to begin with Edward Elgar? He is the genius who gave us the Enigma Variations, including the transcendental Nimrod, and the most beloved Land of Hope and Glory. Now, I don’t want to hate on Stormzy, but in a hundred years’ time, do you think people will still be listening to Pomp and Circumstance, or Vossi Bop?

I haven’t read Zadie Smith. I have read Shakespeare. Lots of Shakespeare. So that’s all I have to say about that.

Sandher is trying to tell a story of diversity. Diversity is our strength, we are told and again. But he has inadvertently told a tragic story of our beloved country’s decline.

Look at what is on his list. A great statesman is put on a par with a serving mayor, about whom the least said the better. A composer of genius is paired with a pop star. A playwright who shaped the English language and inspired the world is matched with a contemporary novelist. There is no ranking, they are all simply placed side by side on a supposedly equal continuum. Greatness is a matter of representation rather than of achievement.

It’s positive he feels proud of being British. It’s sad that his standard of what makes Britain great is set so low.

In an age of TikTok and AI, will there ever be another Shakespeare or Elgar? And who has rivalled the statesmanship of Churchill in recent years? Arguably none since Margaret Thatcher. Perhaps it’s all over, with or without our diversity.

Still, if you want a standard of greatness, try this one.

In 2027 England will be 1,100 years old. On 12 July 927, at Eamont Bridge in Cumbria, the kings of Scotland and Wales acknowledged the overlordship of a man called Æthelstan. Few people have heard of him, but he was the first King of England.

Æthelstan was the grandson of the better-known Alfred the Great, who had laid the foundations for a united England but died before he could achieve it. Alfred’s son, Edward the Elder, and daughter, Æthelflæd, Lady of the Mercians, continued the struggle against the Vikings, gradually bringing more territory under Anglo-Saxon rule.

Æthelstan completed their work. In 927 he defeated the Viking kingdom of York. He took the title Rex Anglorum, King of the English, and established a kingdom that would become the foundation of England.

More than just a warrior, he passed laws against theft and corruption, founded monasteries, promoted learning, was known to be deeply religious and banned the execution of children under 15. As Arthur Bryant wrote in The Story of England, “Physical strength prevailed as it had done since the world began. But for the first time in Northern Europe those who possessed it were made aware that there was something wrong in abusing it.”

Tom Holland, historian and host of The Rest is History, has called for 12 July to become a bank holiday to mark the occasion. Sir Ed Davey has said the 1,100th anniversary “absolutely deserves” one. The government rejected a bank holiday on grounds of cost. This Labour government spent £4 billion on asylum support in the first year of office, including £2.1 billion on asylum hotels.

Conservative MP Neil O’Brien has called for a statue of King Æthelstan to be placed on the fourth plinth in Trafalgar Square. Obviously this would be such a staggering improvement on Lady in Blue by Tschabalala Self that it won’t happen. The fourth plinth has become an irresistible opportunity to humiliate and insult Londoners with works of staggering ugliness and wokery.

The sort of people that cannot tell Churchill from a mayor, or Elgar from a rapper, will not be able to tell Æthelstan from anyone else. Don’t be surprised if we end up with a statue of Sadiq Khan on the fourth plinth if they ever choose to make it permanent.

This article was originally published by the Free Mind.

Latest