Skip to content

Tamatha Paul’s vote, Julie Anne Genter’s culture, and Wellington’s sewage mess

"The consequences are now floating in Cook Strait.”

Table of Contents

Summarised by Centrist

Wellington’s sewage crisis did not come out of nowhere.

Commentator Peter Bassett points to a May 2021 meeting of Wellington City Council’s Long-Term Plan Committee, where councillors were asked to choose between funding cycleways or upgrading water infrastructure. He argues the decision, involving 

Tamatha Paul and Julie Anne Genter, helped set the course for the problems now surfacing.

One option included a $391 million wastewater renewals programme designed to reduce sewage pollution, particularly in the central city and along the south coast. It was explicit, costed, and aimed directly at preventing the failures now closing beaches.

That option was passed over.

Instead, an amendment moved by then-councillor Tamatha Paul and seconded by Robyn Day nearly doubled the city’s original cycleway programme to $226 million. The amendment was passed by a vote of 9 to 5. Accelerated wastewater renewal did not.

“The vote is on video. The numbers are in the Long-Term Plan. The consequences are now floating in Cook Strait,” Bassett writes.

Bassett calls out Green MP Julie Anne Genter (a councillor at the time), long associated with aggressive cycleway advocacy, who has since called for “hard questions” and renewed infrastructure investment.

Paul, by contrast, has said nothing. Bassett notes that no journalist appears to have pressed her to explain why a sewage-focused investment option was rejected in favour of expanded cycleways.

“A city that keeps voting for people who, as Winston Peters once observed, couldn’t operate a school tuck shop, should not be surprised when it ends up ankle-deep in the consequences,” he writes.

Read more over at Breaking Views NZ

Image: Schwede66

Receive our free newsletter here

Latest

The Good Oil Daily Opinion Poll

The Good Oil Daily Opinion Poll

Take our Daily Opinion Poll and see how your views compare to other readers and then share the poll on social media. By sharing the poll you will help even more readers to discover The Good Oil.

Members Public
Where Are the Tea Towels Chlöe?

Where Are the Tea Towels Chlöe?

The dismantling of the Iranian regime will immediately end the war on terror, because the main supplier of that terror will not exist. This, more than anything else, is the key that will unlock the door for peace in the region.

Members Public