Skip to content

Do National MPs Support Luxon?

Luxon has already lost those he has shafted and now he is losing those who will lose their seats because he is so unpopular. 

Sources inside the National caucus say things are pretty dire for Luxon. Not surprisingly Luxon will tell you he has the full confidence of his caucus. Publicly most of caucus will tell you they do have full confidence in Luxon. But the numbers are being run and MPs are being lobbied by potential replacements.

Luxon, being a third grader trying to play in the All Blacks and completely lacking political talent, hasn’t worked out he is not the CEO of a company which has underlings to do his bidding. He has a caucus that are his first employers, and to stay in the job he needs half of them to vote for him. His problem is he is dead set useless and has managed to piss off about a quarter of the caucus by making it clear that they have no future under him. 

This table below shows MPs that Luxon has told: ‘You will not get a promotion with me as leader.’ It also shows the MPs who will likely lose their seats if Luxon stays leader. Charitably, National is polling at down four per cent from election night, and uncharitably as much as eight per cent. This means a lot of National MPs in marginal seats will lose their seat if National’s numbers don’t improve. Anyone with a majority of under 6000 will be vulnerable to the message that, without Luxon, National will win more seats.

Annoyed with Luxon
Electorate Leading candidate Margin
Northland McCALLUM, Grant 6,087 Overlooked for cabinet
New Plymouth MACLEOD, David 6,991 Sacked for failing to declare donations
Tauranga UFFINDELL, Sam 9,370 Limited promotion prospects for historic expulsion from Kings
Invercargill SIMMONDS, Penny 9,874 Sacked for failure in portfolio
Upper Harbour BREWER, Cameron 11,192 Told luxon to get stuffed when he tried to set KPIs
Kaikōura SMITH, Stuart 11,412 Overlooked for cabinet
Whangārei RETI, Shane 11,424 Demoted by Luxon
Waimakariri DOOCEY, Matt 13,010 Demoted by Luxon
Taranaki-King Country KURIGER, Barbara 14,355 Overlooked for cabinet, issues around family farm prosecution for animal cruelty
Southland MOONEY, Joseph 17,211 Overlooked for cabinet
Coromandel SIMPSON, Scott 17,349 Whip not minister despite being a good minister previously
Waikato VAN DE MOLEN, Tim 18,548 No promotion prospects under luxon for bullying
List LEE, Melissa Sacked from cabinet
Port Waikato BAYLY, Andrew Sacked/Resigned from cabinet
Marginal Seat MPs
Electorate Leading candidate Margin
Banks Peninsula WEENINK, Vanessa 396
New Lynn GARCIA, Paulo 1,013
West Coast-Tasman PUGH, Maureen 1,017 Overlooked for Promotion
Hutt South BISHOP, Chris 1,332
Mt Roskill CHEUNG, Carlos 1,564
East Coast KIRKPATRICK, Dana 3,199
Maungakiekie FLEMING, Greg 4,617
Hamilton East HAMILTON, Ryan 5,060
Whanganui BATES, Carl 5,512
Farmers
Rangitīkei REDMAYNE, Suze 9,785 Groundswell can beat them with a good campaign
Waitaki ANDERSON, Miles 12,151
Wairarapa BUTTERICK, Mike 2,816
Not Included Above
Ōtaki COSTLEY, Tim 6,271
Hamilton West POTAKA, Tama William 6,488
Ilam CAMPBELL, Hamish 7,830
Takanini NAKHLE, Rima 8,775
Napier NIMON, Katie 8,909
Rotorua McCLAY, Todd 8,923
Northcote BIDOIS, Dan 9,270
Tukituki WEDD, Catherine 10,118
Rangitata MEAGER, James 10,846
Papakura COLLINS, Judith 13,519
Bay of Plenty RUTHERFORD, Tom 15,405
Botany LUXON, Christopher 16,323
North Shore WATTS, Simon 16,330
Taupō UPSTON, Louise 16,505
Pakuranga BROWN, Simeon 18,710
Kaipara ki Mahurangi PENK, Chris 19,459
Selwyn GRIGG, Nicola 19,782
East Coast Bays STANFORD, Erica 20,353
Whangaparāoa MITCHELL, Mark 23,376
List MPs
Nicola Willis
Gerry Brownlee
Paul Goldsmith
Nancy Lu

There are 48 MPs in caucus, 50 per cent is 24, but effectively you need 25 MPs to roll Luxon, as a tie means the status quo is retained and National limps along with a lame-duck leader.

Luxon has already lost those he has shafted and he is losing those who will lose their seats because he is so unpopular. 

Readers should comment if they know any other MPs who might replace Luxon. 

Latest