Alwyn Poole
alwynpoole.substack.com
Alwyn Poole founded and was the head of Mt Hobson Middle School in Auckland for 18 years. MH Academy is now an in-person private school for Year 11 – 13. There is now a nationwide online provision called Mt Hobson Academy Connected for Years 1 – 13.
Yesterday this headline was in the NZ Herald: Missed opportunity: $3 billion lost in NZ each year due to lack of productivity.
There are two broad sides to determining the general price levels in an economy – the demand side and the supply side. Inflation can be caused by over pumping the money supply making interest rates low and spending relatively easy. Government spending can also play a huge part and there is no doubt that this government, under Grant Robertson, has borrowed [and] spent appalling amounts of money.
When challenged on this Robertson guffaws and repetitively asks people if they would prefer that the government wasn’t investing in education and health. It is a perspective that crumbles under the slightest scrutiny. “Investing” by nature implies a return. We are saying no such return in education (quite the opposite) and, although it is not my field, our health system does not appear to be thriving. A very significant amount of what Robertson is allocating is poorly targeted and highly wasteful. It is a pet hate to hear members of government saying the “they are putting money into … such and such”. It is as if they genuinely forget that it is taxpayers, current and future, that the money belongs to and that it should by no means be spent with impunity.
On the supply side, anything that can improve productivity and/or lower costs for business can increase supply and put downward pressure on prices. Possible measures to consider are free trade in business inputs, well-targeted immigration, decreasing GST and other business taxes, reducing business compliance costs and, of course, a fabulous education system.
A fabulous education system is one that caters to the needs of every child and engages every family. It is one that provides deep foundations in numeracy and literacy. It is one where schools are well lead, where teachers are passionate experts. It is one where young people emerge highly informed, skilled at learning, free and critical thinkers and with high aspirations for life and careers. Our education system is, at present, far from fabulous.
At present we have become focussed on attendance. It is a symptom of deeper systemic issues. That 57 per cent of students only are attending fully is the number often quoted. For decile one and two students things are, of course, much worse. They attend fully at less than 40 per cent.
One of the ridiculous things about the recent Education and Workforce Select Committee inquiry into attendance is that only 6/2600 schools bothered to submit. The recommendations Hipkins/Tinetti chose to implement were very poorly researched. The report is another bad education joke. I saw Jan Tinetti recently and asked why members of the committee did not go out to 15 schools where attendance is low and 15 where it is high and find out why in both? Surely the key thing they needed to know.
She had no answer because the truth is that a significant amount of fault would fall back on the quality of schools and their programmes, the quality of school leaders and teachers and the oversight of the ministry. These are not things this government would wish to admit.
Why would a child go to school if the school is of poor quality, they are not learning much and they just don’t see the point. So much happens in our schools that has nothing to do with the education of young people and kids see through it.
Long-term improvement in attendance requires massive improvement in our schools. The children have to be drawn back and then effectively engaged. They, and their parents, need to see the point. This clearly does happen in some of our schools. New Zealand needs to learn from those exemplars.
It is no quick fix for current inflation, but generating a highly productive and aspirational workforce through education, that works for children of all kinds and regardless of socio-economic background, is the key to long-term health of the economy and nation.
Alwyn Poole
Innovative Education Consultants
