Skip to content

Experts want to fix MMP, but what if voters were trying to fix National?

Forty-six experts are calling for urgent electoral reform after New Zealand's preliminary election results produced an unprecedented 11-seat overhang.

Summarised by Centrist

Forty-six experts are calling for urgent electoral reform after New Zealand's preliminary election results produced an unprecedented 11-seat overhang. 

But the debate raises another possibility: what if National's overhang was less about voters manipulating the system and more about dissatisfied supporters trying to hold their government to account?

An open letter led by Andrew Geddis, Lara Greaves and Max Rashbrooke warns that overhangs threaten proportional representation.

National's party vote plunged from 38.08% in 2023 to 29.21% in 2026, yet the party retained 42 electorate seats, producing a seven-seat overhang.

Meanwhile, ACT and NZ First increased their support. An RNZ–Reid Research poll before the election found 18.4% of National's 2023 voters had switched to its coalition partners.

The pattern is consistent with voters retaining their preferred local National MPs while redirecting party votes, potentially to demand more from the government they elected in 2023.

Geddis acknowledged National's overhang was largely an "organic result" of its declining party vote, contrasting it with Te Pāti Māori's deliberate campaign to secure electorate seats while encouraging party votes for Labour or the Greens.

Nevertheless, he declared the outcome "definitely not the way MMP was supposed to work".

Rashbrooke warned tactical voting could become an electoral "arms race".

The experts propose remedies ranging from expanding Parliament to restricting overhang seats or replacing the two-vote system.

Editor's note: Voters elected a government promising change in 2023. By 2026, some may have concluded National had failed to deliver enough of it, choosing instead to strengthen its coalition partners while retaining their local representatives.

The results cannot establish every voter's motivation. Nevertheless, if politicians are worried that voters will repeat this behaviour, shouldn't they first ask what drove voters to abandon their party in the first place?

One possible answer to strategic defections is to simply understand voters' expectations, honour election commitments and deliver the changes promised.

Read more at RNZ

Re-published from the Centrist with permission

Original article at The Centrist

Latest

Quick Hit

Quick Hit: The RNZ CFO Timeline

RNZ’s finance chief raised ‘differences’ in the accounts on 2 October and resigned at 8.46pm. A board member was offered the job the next morning. The minister was told on Monday. The emails are still withheld.

Members Public
An Unelected Opposition

An Unelected Opposition

A survey of 718 public servants found 55 per cent would brief the media to make a minister’s policy politically untenable. The next coalition agreement needs a clause for the public service, not just the ministers.

Members Public