Skip to content
Covid-19FeaturedNZ

Fact Check on Dr Leighton Watson’s Claim

letter to the editor letters

Table of Contents

Dear Editor

https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2022/03/data-from-delta-and-omicron-outbreaks-show-1-in-15-unvaccinated-cases-were-hospitalised-significantly-more-than-vaccinated-cases.html

I read the article above with interest. The article quotes Dr Leighton Watson, a mathematician as stating, “But there are 27 times as many vaccinated people in New Zealand as unvaccinated.”

According to government data https://www.health.govt.nz/covid-19-novel-coronavirus/covid-19-data-and-statistics/covid-19-vaccine-data
4,021,400 people have been vaccinated with at least one dose.

According to ONS (https://www.stats.govt.nz/topics/population) the population of New Zealand is 5,127,200. So that means there are 1,105,800 unvaccinated people in New Zealand.

To check the claim, ’27 times as many vaccinated people in New Zealand as unvaccinated’, we multiply 1,105,800 by 27 and should get around 4 million. The actual answer is 29,856,600, which is substantially different from 4 million. The ratio appears closer to 4.6 suggesting a contrary conclusion to the main thrust of the article.

It would appear at first glance that the mathematician has made some fundamental arithmetical errors. I’d welcome your comment on this seemingly glaring error.

Kind regards,
Andy
Christchurch

Latest

Quick Hit – Luxon and Peters Wedge Labour: No Grand Coalition as TPM Implodes

Quick Hit – Luxon and Peters Wedge Labour: No Grand Coalition as TPM Implodes

🔴 VIP EARLY ACCESS Rapid Intelligence Briefing | 12 May 2026 | Stuff.co.nz + open source | High Confidence | Medium-High Urgency EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has categorically ruled out any grand coalition with Labour, calling the notion “insanity” while he cleans up the previous government’s mess. Winston Peters has done

Members Public
Face of the Day

Face of the Day

Whanau’s evidence was to the Tribunal’s Mana Wāhine inquiry into issues affecting Māori women, including whether the Crown’s systems and institutions failed to protect and support Māori women in leadership, governance and public life.

Members Public
The Good Oil Word of the Day

The Good Oil Word of the Day

The word for today is… interregnum (noun) - 1: the time during which a throne is vacant between two successive reigns or regimes 2: a period during which the normal functions of government or control are suspended 3: a lapse or pause in a continuous series Source : Merriam-Webster Etymology : Every

Members Public