Skip to content

Government Inaction Putting Children at Risk

rusting Motel signage during daytime
Photo by Nicolas Cool. The BFD.

The Ministry of Social Development has only just begun ‘scoping’ an information-sharing arrangement with Police to improve outcomes for Kiwis in emergency housing, despite already having the information it needs, National’s Social Development and Employment spokesperson Louise Upston says.

“For months we’ve heard police report incidents of violence, intimidation, public urination, drug deals and gang involvement are happening at MSD emergency motels, so it beggars belief Government has just realised Police and MSD should work together to combat this.

“With more than 4000 children in emergency housing the Government should’ve been using all the tools it has to minimise safety risks at emergency housing motels.

“Ministers might well try and blame their departments for belated action, but the Government should be showing leadership given their own inaction is the reason more children are growing up in motels.

“The Government doesn’t seem to see the seriousness of the problem. It was relying on gang members to declare themselves as affiliated to a gang rather than using the Gang Intelligence Centre. What other basic precautions has the Government failed to take after four years?

“MSD already receives information from the Gang Intelligence Centre. Rather than beginning a ‘scoping’ process, the Government should just get on with it and make MSD use this information to keep children out of harm’s way.

“Every day that passes is another day when the risk of staying in emergency housing is greater than it should be.

“For months National have called for simple measures like cohorting to reduce the risks children are exposed to. The Government instead made a few announcements in Rotorua, which means nothing to those living in emergency housing motels throughout New Zealand.

“The Government must stop placing vulnerable families in motels without adequate support or regard to the risks they are exposed to. Leaving more than 4000 children to live in a motel exposed to violence, drug use and gang activity is an utter disgrace.”

Note: Relevant WPQs are below.

WPQ 28009 (2021)

Question

Further to WPQ 25195 (2021), if it’s correct “this perception [increasing levels of crime] is not necessarily the reality”, what data, if any, demonstrates it’s not the reality; for what reasons, if any,  will Government Ministers not disclose the number of call-outs or incidents at emergency accommodation locations?

Reply

I am advised by the Ministry of Social Development that they do not directly respond to call-outs or incidents at or around emergency housing related to criminal activity. In emergency or urgent situations, the Ministry would encourage those involved, or those witnessing an incident, to contact  Police directly. I am also advised that Police is currently engaging with the Ministry of Social  Development on scoping potential information sharing arrangements. Information sharing may assist agencies to identify any issues in and around Emergency Housing, potentially providing opportunities to achieve better outcomes for people placed in emergency housing.

WPQ 25718 (2021)

Question

How is the Information Sharing Agreement between MSD and the Gang Intelligence Unit utilised, if at all, to maximise the safety of people staying in or near emergency accommodation and housing  (inclusive of approved suppliers to EHSNG recipients); if the agreement is not utilised for this purpose, why is it not?

Reply

I am advised by the Ministry of Social Development (the Ministry) that the Ministry periodically receives updates to the National Gang List from the GIC. The Ministry has

Please share this BFD article so others can discover The BFD.

Latest