Once again, in memibus veritas, to coin a phrase: memes are more truthful than politicians. That is a low bar, granted, but right now Australians are getting an object lesson in this truism.
The first applicable meme is, It’s amazing how much leftist discourse is just them pretending not to understand things, thus making discourse impossible. The other is Step 1: It’s not really happening. Step 2: Yeah, it’s happening, but it’s not a big deal. Step 3: It’s a good thing, actually. Step 4: People freaking out about it are the real problem.
The ‘it’, in this case, is the Great Replacement Theory. And the latest round of leftist hyperventilating because someone dared notice it in public.
NSW Labor Minister Rose Jackson: “The Great Replacement Theory is one of those crazy tinfoil hat conspiracy theories from the dark edges of the internet that says there is a grand plan to actively replace white people with people from other cultures in our country.”
Rose might like to take that up with her Labor colleague, South Australian Premier Peter Malinauskas. He recently delivered a speech arguing that native-born Australians are a fiscal burden and that the sensible course is to swap them out for migrants.
“Here’s the ripping beauty of skilled migrants: they arrive job-ready at relatively low cost. A couple of years ago, federal Treasury estimated that the average Australian-born resident – Aussies born here – has a lifetime net cost to public budgets of $85,000. Whereas average skilled migrants deliver a net $198,000 benefit to public budgets over their lifetime in this country.”
Never mind that Malinauskas’ claims are a farrago of lies: not least that the merest fraction of the millions of Third World foreigners imported in the last decade are even laughingly classified as “skilled”, and many of that tiny percentage are such in-demand ‘skills’ as massage therapists and Uber drivers. This is on the government’s own data.
Nor is noticing the left’s own words the prerogative of tinfoil hat-wearers.
Jackson might also take it up with Greens Senator Mehreen Faruqi, who openly cheers the replacement of Anglo-European Australia.
“This country is changing, our community is changing and our parliament is changing. More than half of us were born overseas or have a parent born overseas and a quarter of us have a non-European background.”
Malinauskas has been more, still, declaring that Australia would be bland and dull without recent waves of multicultural migration. Victorian Labor Premier Jacinta Allan has called Australia a “nation of foreigners”. The message received by millions of Australians whose families have been here for generations is that they are temporary guests whose culture was insufficient until it was ‘enriched’.
Against this rhetorical backdrop, the numbers have moved. The European-descended share of the population has fallen from about 90 per cent in 2000 to roughly 68 per cent now. On the current migration trajectory, that share becomes a minority within 20 to 25 years. That is not a conspiracy theory. It is arithmetic. Not to mention perhaps the most dramatic demographic transition in human history, short of outright genocide.
Just in case the left want to pretend the numbers are just a coincidence, the United Nations Population Division came right out and said it, a quarter-century ago. Its Replacement Migration report (2000) advocated international migration for Western nations. The report defined replacement migration as the international migration required to prevent natural birth rate declines declines and explicitly discussed the policy implications of importing large numbers of migrants. Western countries with sub-replacement fertility were the target. The document does not hide its purpose in the title.
None of this requires a secret cabal. Mass migration produces massive demographic change. Every Western country is undergoing it. Part of the driver is economic (however spurious the ‘economics’) – part of it is ideological. Many on the left simply hate Western civilisation and regard multiculturalism and high immigration as a kind atonement for some imagined original civilisation sin, on the argument that racism is uniquely a white pathology.
It isn’t, of course. Most Global South societies are more tribal and more ethnically hierarchical than Western liberal democracies. As surveys in places like South Africa show, even black Africans hate other black Africans with all the loathing of a pre-Civil Rights Klansman.
The meme is accurate. First it is not happening. Then it is happening but not a big deal. Then it is a good thing. Then the people who notice are the problem. Rose Jackson is currently on step one. The premiers, the Greens, the prime minister and a United Nations study have already gone all the way to step four.
The rest of us are not obliged to pretend we cannot read.