Skip to content

Paying members showed up. Here’s what 257 of you told me.

Nearly one in four paying members answered the Good Oil survey. Only one in 25 free readers did. Here’s why you pay, what you value and who you are.

Reader Survey Results, November 2026: 96% of paying members are staying

On Saturday I sent two short surveys, one to paying members and one to free readers. I wanted to know why you pay, what you value, what you’d change and who you are. By Monday the answers were in and the first thing they told me had nothing to do with any single question.

Nearly one in four paying members answered: 257 out of 1,132, or 23 per cent. Only 28 of 695 free readers did, about four per cent, or one in 25.

That gap says it all. People who pay are engaged. They read most days, they turn up in General Debate and Backchat and when I asked for their time they gave it. They recognise the value. Most free readers didn’t care enough to fill in a form that took a few minutes. I’m not complaining. The numbers just say it plainly and they tell me exactly who keeps this place running.

So most of what follows comes from the 257 paying members. Where I quote free readers, treat the numbers as indicative only, because 28 people is too small a sample to lean on.

Why you pay

The top reason by a mile is to support independent media and my work: 86 per cent ticked it. Next is trust: 72 per cent said they trust the Good Oil more than the mainstream media. Sixty per cent pay for the commentary and analysis and 56 per cent say it’s simply good value for what they get.

Very few of you pay for the extras. Only eight per cent ticked the MP dossiers and Good Oil AI as a reason. You pay because you want this to exist.

Supporting independent media and Cam's work is the top reason members pay (86%)
Source: Good Oil member survey, 14–16 Nov 2026

What you value most

Asked to pick up to three, 83 per cent of paying members chose my commentary and analysis. The General Debate and Backchat community came second at 52 per cent, then Satire and Comedy Corner at 37 per cent. Election and polling coverage and Ten@10 were both on 22 per cent.

You also read a lot: 54 per cent of paying members visit or open an email several times a day, and another 35 per cent about once a day. That’s 89 per cent of you here every single day.

Would you recommend us?

I asked how likely you’d be to recommend the Good Oil to a friend, on a scale from 0 to 10. Fifty-seven per cent gave a 9 or a 10. Only 10 per cent gave a 6 or lower. Ninety-four of you gave it a straight 10 and the average score was 8.5.

Survey people turn those answers into one number, called a Net Promoter Score. You take the share who would actively recommend us (the 9s and 10s) and subtract the share who wouldn’t (0 to 6). For us that’s 57 minus 10, which gives +47. That’s well into good territory and close to excellent.

Most paying members are promoters, giving The Good Oil a Net Promoter Score of +47
Source: Good Oil member survey, 14–16 Nov 2026

Value for money, and staying put

Ninety-three per cent of paying members rate their membership as excellent (62%) or good (31%) value for money. Only three people said poor.

Ninety-six expect to keep their membership for the next 12 months: 77 per cent are definitely staying and 19 per cent probably. Just five of 256 said they’re thinking about cancelling or planning to.

When I asked what’s behind it for anyone who has ever thought about cancelling, 70 per cent said they hadn’t thought about it at all. The biggest reason among the rest was money being tight (18%). A lot of you are retired and I don’t take that lightly.

More than nine in ten paying members rate the value as good or excellent and expect to stay
Source: Good Oil member survey, 14–16 Nov 2026

What extras you’d like

MP dossiers and research reports drew the most interest: 81 per cent of those who answered were somewhat or very interested. Live Q&A sessions with me (60%) and podcasts or audio versions (59%) came next. Gift memberships drew the least, at 36 per cent.

To be straight about it, most of that interest is “somewhat”. “Very interested” sits between six per cent and 20 per cent for every extra. So the core is the core, and anything new has to earn its place.

Those MP dossiers are freely available to VIP members – it is included in their membership package. I sell these at $15 each, so it is well worth while upgrading to VIP to gain full access.

Four in five paying members are interested in MP dossiers and research reports; gift memberships draw the least interest
Source: Good Oil member survey, 14–16 Nov 2026

In your own words

You wrote 302 answers in the free-text boxes, and I’ve read every one. Two hundred told me what they’d miss most if the Good Oil stopped tomorrow and 102 told me one thing to improve.

What you’d miss falls into four piles. The commentary. The community in General Debate and Backchat, which a lot of you describe as friends you’ve never met. Having a trusted alternative to the mainstream media. And the lighter stuff: the cartoons, Comedy Corner, the puzzles and the daily roundup. A fair few just wrote “all of it”.

“It’s my daily newspaper. Happy to pay a higher membership fee.”
“Comradery, it feels like I’m with friends on the site.”
“A trustworthy alternative to the mainstream media.”

On improvements, the most common answer was some version of ‘leave it alone’. The most common practical gripe was logging in: having to sign in again on every device, codes that take too long to arrive and not being able to stay logged in on two devices at once. A handful asked for a step between Basic+ and VIP, and a few want audio or the podcasts back. Some of you think there’s been too much polling and election coverage lately and a few think I’ve been too hard on Luxon. Fair enough. I asked and you told me.

I’m reading every comment, and the login complaints are top of my list. The quickest and easiest way to solve that is to whitelist our site in your browser setting for cookies. That way you’ll only have to log in once every six months.

Who reads the Good Oil

Our paying members are experienced readers. Thirty-six per cent have been reading me for more than 10 years, going back to the Whaleoil days, and another 32 per cent for five to 10 years.

About three in four paying members are 65 or over (188 of 251), and 21 per cent are 55 to 64. Sixty-one per cent own their home, 58 per cent are retired and 21 per cent own an investment or rental property. Auckland is the biggest region at 30 per cent, then Waikato (14%), Canterbury (11%) and Wellington (10%).

About three in four paying members are 65 or over
Source: Good Oil member survey, 14–16 Nov 2026

I also asked what you’re likely to buy, switch or seriously look at in the next 12 months. Travel leads at 55 per cent. Insurance and books, gifts or NZ-made products are both on 35 per cent, and 25 per cent are looking at a new or used ute, 4WD or car. Retirement planning or living (23%), property (19%) and tools, sheds or building supplies (19%) follow.

Travel tops paying members' plans for the next 12 months, at 55%
Source: Good Oil member survey, 14–16 Nov 2026

Business partners and a note for sponsors

I asked how you’d feel about a small number of New Zealand business partners, clearly labelled, to help keep the Good Oil independent. Eighty-seven per cent of paying members are either supportive if the partners are a good fit (65%) or fine with it as long as it’s clearly labelled and limited (22%). Only five per cent would prefer not, and even they said they understand.

That’s a clear yes, with conditions I agree with. Any partner has to be a New Zealand business that fits with our readers, it will always be labelled and there won’t be many of them.

Nearly nine in ten paying members are supportive of, or fine with, a few clearly labelled NZ business partners
Source: Good Oil member survey, 14–16 Nov 2026

If you run a New Zealand business, here’s who you’d be talking to. These figures are from paying members who answered the November survey:

  • A loyal, daily audience. Eighty nine per cent of paying members who answered are here every day and 96 per cent plan to stay another year.
  • Readers with means and time. About three in four who answered are 65 or over, 61 per cent own their home and 58 per cent are retired.
  • People with plans to spend. Fifty-five per cent of those who answered plan to travel in the next year, 35 per cent are looking at insurance and 25 per cent at a vehicle.
  • An audience that’s open to you. Eighty-seven per cent of those who answered are supportive of, or fine with, clearly labelled NZ partners.

If they sounds like your customers, get in touch through the contact page and ask for the sponsorship details.

What free readers told us

A reminder that only 28 free readers answered, so treat these numbers as indicative, not gospel.

Forty-four per cent of them used to pay and stopped. The biggest single reason for not paying now is money being tight, given by nine of the 27 who answered that question. Forty per cent say nothing would make them pay. Thirty-two per cent say knowing their money keeps independent media going would and nearly half think under $10 a month is fair.

Of 27 free readers who answered, a third gave money's tight as their main reason
Source: Good Oil member survey, 14–16 Nov 2026

If you’re a free reader and money is the only thing stopping you, Basic is $5 a month. If you can do more, Good Oil News VIP gets you everything, including Good Oil AI Insight. You can see the plans here.

Thank you

To the 285 of you who took the time, thank you. To the 257 paying members in particular: you answered in your hundreds, inside two days and you made it plain why this place works. You keep it independent and I don’t forget it.

How the survey worked

Two online surveys were emailed on Saturday 14 November 2026: one to 1,132 paying members, which got 257 unique responses (23%), and one to 695 free readers, which got 28 (4%). Responses were counted up to Monday 16 November. Duplicate submissions from the same member were removed. People chose whether to answer and the results aren’t weighted. Percentages are of those who answered each question, and where you could tick more than one answer the totals add up to more than 100 per cent. Written answers are quoted without names.

Latest

The Losers Want New Rules

The Losers Want New Rules

Nine days after the vote, former MPs want an unelected Future Generations commissioner no minister can direct and MMP’s academic defenders want a rewrite, because an 11-seat overhang arrived at scale. The official result is still not in.

Members Public