Skip to content

One Nation Offers a Real Migration Choice

While the uniparty tinkers with window dressing, ON cuts to the chase.

Only one party will put a stop to this. The Good Oil. Image by Lushington Brady.

As both Labor and the coalition back down on any meaningful reform of mass migration, One Nation is going in boots and all. The uniparty is trying to get away with tinkering around at the edges and calling it ‘reform’. One Nation is cutting straight to the heart of the scam: fakefugees and importing the geriatric leeches of the Third World.

Under Pauline Hanson’s latest plan, the annual refugee intake would be slashed from 20,000 to 2,000. The roughly 7,000 parent and grandparent visas granted each year would be abolished entirely. Parents and grandparents could still visit on three-, six- or 12-month visitor visas, but the permanent free ride on the taxpayer would end. Onshore asylum applications, the classic fakefugee loophole that clogs the system with endless vexatious lawfare, would be banned. One Nation argues that even at 2,000 a year Australia would remain above the OECD average for per-capita refugee intake. It would end our status as one of the most generous developed countries outside Canada, where Mark Carney has already begun winding back the same visas.

“Migrants have helped build Australia, and we remain a generous country, but we must look after Australians first.”

The policy rests on Treasury estimates that parent and refugee arrivals cost federal and state taxpayers more than $500,000 over their lifetimes, largely because of lower workforce participation. Skilled migrants, by contrast, contribute a net $260,000.

The only problem: ‘skilled’ migrants are barely one-tenth of the millions of Third Worlders who’ve flooded Australia in the last decade. Even then, a large proportion of that tiny minority of ‘skilled’ migrants are such in-demand skills as massage therapists, Uber drivers and even dog walkers. As for the skills we desperately need, such as builders, watch the Site Inspections YouTube channel and ask yourself if we’re getting anything remotely resembling value for money.

One Nation’s own calculations put the lifetime saving at $140 billion in today’s dollars under Labor’s current settings. The figures were not costed by the Parliamentary Budget Office – they rest on Treasury modelling of the visa classes. That is more than Labor or the coalition have ever been prepared to publish on the same categories. Labor and the coalition have both been forced to acknowledge the post-pandemic surge that began under Scott Morrison and was reined in too slowly by Labor has damaged housing.

Labor was also considering cutting the humanitarian program from 20,000 to the long-run base figure of 13,750 but reversed course after a backlash from its own MPs, costing the budget $1 billion. Opposition Leader Angus Taylor, who, like Labor, was pressured by One Nation to make deep cuts, has pledged to halve the 20,000 intake.

On Tuesday Tony Burke was forced into his second reversal on Labor’s migration overhaul. Cabinet had earlier baulked at his proposals and he cancelled a press club speech. When the details finally emerged, the main target was the one class of people who actually go home without any fuss: the working backpacker. After a well-organised campaign by regional businesses warning of labour shortages, the planned cut in third-year working holidaymakers from an earlier proposal of 5,000 was adjusted to 25,000. Backpackers will need an extra month of regional work for their second-year visa.

The stark difference between One Nation and the uniparty is that one side starts from the premise that Australians must come first; the other starts from the premise that foreigners are more important than Australians.

Assistant minister Patrick Gorman, speaking at the Sydney Institute, suggested Hanson wanted to create a “discriminatory migration system like the old one based on race or religion”. OK: and? What, exactly, is wrong about being discriminating in our national choices? The antonyms of discriminating, of course, are ‘undemanding’, ‘careless’, and ‘thoughtless’.

Which would Australians rather our government be?

The race card is the last refuge of a policy that has already collapsed under its own weight. Parent visas and a 20,000 refugee intake are not sacred. They are expensive choices. When Treasury itself shows the lifetime bill running past half a million dollars a head, and when housing, hospitals and aged care are already rationed, the only people who find that unremarkable are those who do not have to live with the consequences.

One Nation is the only party prepared to name the scam and cut it. The uniparty will keep calling its retreats reform until the voters stop listening.


💡
If you enjoyed this article please share it using the share buttons at the top or bottom of the article.

Latest