If Chris Hipkins is still hoping to be prime minister at the end of the year, then one of the things he’ll be looking forward to doing is closing down the charter schools again, as he did in 2017. Charter schools are bad, apparently, because they don’t have to follow the same rules as the state schools and therefore they are not “accountable to the community”. They also may operate out of leased premises, which means that they can be closed “at the drop of a hat”.
It’s amazing what short memories people have. The former minister for COVID-19 Response, who closed all the schools in the country ‘at the drop of a hat’ and then failed to front at the Royal Commission, is New Zealanders’ first choice for prime minister, and they take him seriously when he says he wants other people to be accountable to the community.
Charter schools are out-performing the state schools and doing it on less money. Why? Simple: they are accountable to the community. No one is being forced to go to them. If the customers don’t like what they offer, they can stay away. And for good measure, if charter schools fail to meet the targets that they have set for themselves, the ministry can effectively close them down by withdrawing their funding.
Not that being accountable to the ministry of *Marxist indoctrination* equates to being accountable to the community. The government is not the voice of the people; the market is.
The free market is a wonderful thing. It brings supply and demand into balance easily, effortlessly, at no extra cost and often by the close of the business day. By contrast, when the government controls supply and demand, as it does under communism, everything is either in surplus or in deficit and economic problems persist for decades. The same is true of education, because commodified education is part of the economy. Take an obvious example: generations of children have grown up with their parents clamouring for “more emphasis on the three Rs”, and it took until the current term of government for political pressure to make it happen. An entire half of the school day must now be devoted to reading, writing and maths (what did they use to do with all that time?) and Mr Luxon has been beaming with pride over it. But a change of government could sweep those changes into the rubbish bin and school parents back into the chamber of silence.
Charter schools are an obvious way that sections of the community can have more of what they want, and have it now, rather than having to wait until they have great-grandchildren for an election result to deliver changes.
Chris Hipkins and the teachers’ unions say they want the available resources to be devoted to a state school system that benefits everybody, and that they are fighting for “quality education”. That sounds distinctly Orwellian, given that what the unions want in practice is collective bargaining rights, the elimination of competition and a monopoly on what they provide. Personally, I think I would put more confidence in the free market.