Skip to content

Can’t Read, Can’t Think, Can Only Protest

US schools have shrunk their students’ vocabularies dramatically.

A zoomer tries to read The Very Hungry Caterpillar. The Good Oil.

George Orwell’s great observation, in 1984, was that to shrink one’s vocabulary is to shrink the capacity to think. Hence, the Party was dedicated above all to “the destruction of language,” as the character Syme approvingly states.

“Don’t you see that the whole aim of Newspeak is to narrow the range of thought? In the end we shall make thoughtcrime literally impossible, because there will be no words in which to express it” – George Orwell, 1984

An impoverished version of English removes the mental tools needed to formulate and communicate complex (and of course, dissenting) ideas, which is exactly what the left-dominated education bureaucracy is delivering. A new study from the USA shows just how far the dumbing-down has gone: the vocabulary of high school graduates has collapsed. The test barely tests vocabulary at all. Where the old test forced students to know a wide range of words through analogies, antonyms and sentence completions, the new test just gets them to fill in a single blank word in a sentence. The reading passages have got dramatically shorter: down from over 300 words to less than 100.

“The makers of the SAT seem to believe that the ability to tackle long and complex literary works isn’t an important skill for college students any more,” says [Thomas Aquinas College Vice President and Dean Emeritus John J Goyette]. “Sadly, given the state of modern higher education, they’re probably right.”

The report compares SAT forms from 1980 and 1987 with a current College Board practice test. It documents extensive modifications to the reading section over four decades, most of which diminish the emphasis on reading and analysing difficult texts. Passages are now less than a third of their former length. Vocabulary questions requiring independent word knowledge have dropped sharply, from 60 per test to 10. Argumentative and persuasive readings have been nearly eliminated, replaced by expository texts. Passages that once assumed prior knowledge have been swapped for ones that reveal their meanings through contextual clues.

“This shift is significant because reading, vocabulary, and comprehension are mutually reinforcing,” the study’s authors observe. “As students read more, both the breadth (number of words known) and the depth (quality of word understanding) of their vocabulary increase, which in turn supports stronger reading comprehension.”

For more than 50 years, Thomas Aquinas College has relied on the SAT to evaluate applicants. Since the 1980s the exam has undergone multiple transformations, leading officials to question whether it still measures the same qualifications, and whether scores can be fairly compared across time.

“We wanted to get a sense of the long-term value of the SAT as an admissions tool,” says Dr Goyette. “We also wanted to see what its changes can tell us about recent trends in American higher education. To our surprise, no one had conducted a careful, independent comparison of what the test asked of students then and now. So, we commissioned this study.”

The results were not promising for a college whose curriculum is drawn entirely from the greatest works of the Western intellectual tradition: texts that are long, arduous, sometimes convoluted and demand a strong vocabulary and the ability to reason. Instead, students are being dumbed-down for a college system that apparently wants nothing more than obedient, brain-dead, perpetually aggrieved robots, fit only to swell the ranks of the activist class.

“Since few colleges still ask students to read the great works, it is not surprising that the test has moved in the same direction,” says Dr Goyette.

The authors describe the changes as a “redistribution rather than simple reduction” of demands, and draw no conclusions about relative difficulty. Four of the five findings suggest the newer SAT demands less of the test-taker; the fifth, text complexity, suggests the opposite.

Johns Hopkins researchers note that the SAT is among the most consequential assessments in American education, shaping what schools, tutors and families emphasise. A change in the reading section ripples back into classrooms. As the most widely used measure of prospective college students’ abilities, it also reflects what most colleges now deem necessary for success.

The education bureaucracy has delivered precisely the Newspeak Orwell described. Complex, dissenting ideas require words. When those words are systematically removed from the tests that shape schooling, the capacity to think them shrinks with them.


💡
If you enjoyed this article please share it using the share buttons at the top or bottom of the article.

Latest

Quick Hit

Quick Hit: The RNZ CFO Timeline

RNZ’s finance chief raised ‘differences’ in the accounts on 2 October and resigned at 8.46pm. A board member was offered the job the next morning. The minister was told on Monday. The emails are still withheld.

Members Public
An Unelected Opposition

An Unelected Opposition

A survey of 718 public servants found 55 per cent would brief the media to make a minister’s policy politically untenable. The next coalition agreement needs a clause for the public service, not just the ministers.

Members Public