Skip to content

Goodbye to You and You and You

I don’t see anything changing without a leadership change. There are now no list MPs, only electorate MPs from largely conservative regions. What this means is Luxon will be facing even more internal opposition to his more liberal approach.

Image credit: Wikifan0653/https://20thcenturystudios.fandom.com/wiki/So_Long,_Farewell

If the headline rings a bell in the ears of the more mature of the Good Oilers it should. It’s a line from a song in the Sound of Music. The song is “So Long Farewell”. Post election, I suspect the sound of music is not what’s ringing in the ears of the National Party. But I suspect ‘So Long, Farewell’ is. Because it really is time to say good bye to you and you and you. Of the seven departing, I regard one as a definite loss (Bishop), one as a partial loss (Willis), one is past his use by date (Brownlee), one can go back to writing books (Goldsmith), one I feel somewhat sorry for (Lee), one I’m not sure I know (Liu) and one, from her comments, was in the wrong party to begin with (Weenink).

This is a sad commentary on the party itself. Luxon says they’re his friends. No doubt they are but he has dealt them an awful hand. They were on a hiding to nothing from the start. The polls, week after week, were blowing the equivalent of the Swiss alpenhorn warning them of what lay ahead. But instead of climbing every mountain, fording every stream and following every rainbow, they failed to heed the warning and so never found their dream. The National Party’s strategy sealed their fate.

There is an eighth person to whom we should be saying goodbye and that is Luxon. My observations are not of him as a person but rather as a politician. I’m sure he’s a very nice guy whose company I would find very convivial. That in itself is not enough to carve out a career as a successful politician. You have to have what is commonly known as ‘political nous’. You have to be able to take people with you. You have to be able to ‘read the room’. You have to implement your election commitments. You have to be true to your party’s founding principles. In my opinion Luxon failed on all these points.

What he did succeed in doing was splitting the party into two factions – liberals and conservatives. National is a conservative party. This is evidenced plainly by looking at the electorates it wins. They are mainly provincial and rural. Outside of east and north Auckland metropolitan areas it holds no urban or metropolitan seats, bar Ilam in Christchurch. People living in provincial and rural areas lean far more conservative than liberal. What Luxon did was take the party away from its conservative base by introducing a Labour-lite liberal agenda.

This is why he found himself leading a divided party on a downward trajectory in the polls. Those MPs representing the provinces and rural communities found themselves having to defend against a direction with which they didn’t agree. The upshot of that was two leadership coups which forced him to remove his imaginary political hat, don his real CEO hat and, as a result, seize back control. This type of behaviour is not how a leader of a political party should operate.

It illustrates most of the points I have listed above: a lack of political nous, not taking people with you, not reading the room and not being true to his party’s founding principles. In addition to all of that were the polls. When polls are all over the place, such as the rubbishy Herald ‘Poll of Polls’, carefully constructed so that the results for Opportunity were in line with their narrative, they can be ignored. But when a certain number in a poll consistently shows a problem, notice should be taken. Luxon chose not to and the result of that decision became apparent on 7 November.

The folly of taking that path results in goodbye to you and you and you plus four more. In my view his time is up and he should become the number eight. Taking a sporting analogy, in rugby the number 8 is a playmaker supposed to possess great handling and vision. In terms of handling I’ll give Luxon credit for holding the coalition together. But his handling of National’s MPs created a divided party. His vision was all about what he wanted and not what most of his MPs wanted nor indeed most of those who had voted for him wanted.

I don’t see anything changing without a leadership change. National has only electorate MPs from largely conservative regions. What this means is Luxon will be facing even more opposition to his liberal approach. His two high ranking lieutenants are gone. Erica Stanford and, to a lesser extent, Mark Mitchell could be regarded as most closely linked to his political course of action. Both could be contenders in any subsequent leadership contest. I think both are capable of succeeding in the areas where Luxon has failed.

So National’s future, good or bad, is now in the hands of its provincial and rural MPs. With no list members, they have the opportunity to set the direction and tone for the National Party of the future. Auckland metropolitan electorates must not be overlooked but mostly have high ranking MPs – Simeon Brown, Mark Mitchell, Erica Stanford and Simon Watts, so will be well looked after. These members between them, metro, provincial and rural, need to ensure National gets back on track as a force to be reckoned with. At least some of the party vote must be regained. A strong National Party is the best base for a good right-wing coalition.

I have written many articles criticising the National Party but I wish them well in their endeavours to hopefully return the party to its roots. Now is the time but a certain amount of courage and fortitude will be needed. All I can say is good luck!

Latest

The Losers Want New Rules

The Losers Want New Rules

Nine days after the vote, former MPs want an unelected Future Generations commissioner no minister can direct and MMP’s academic defenders want a rewrite, because an 11-seat overhang arrived at scale. The official result is still not in.

Members Public