Skip to content

What on Earth Is She on About?

‘Anti-fascist economics’ sounds a lot like fascism.

Isabella Weber: doesn’t appear to even know what ‘fascism’ really is. The Good Oil. Image by Lushington Brady.

As George Orwell wrote so long ago, a great deal of nonsense is allowed to poison the public square simply because so few people stop to critically examine buzzwords. The worst offenders when it comes to nonsense, as Orwell also pointed out, are the so-called ‘intelligentsia’.

Case in point, a “rising-star German economist” who babbles about ‘fascism’ while clearly not understanding what on earth she’s talking about.

Isabella Weber, the rising-star German economist in question, has been busy telling the ABC that “anti-fascist economics” is something we need to pursue again. She says fascism has made a comeback. No shred of evidence is offered for any of this. Just the familiar assertion that anyone to the right of the centre is a fascist, and that the only cure is more state control.

Given that she plainly does not know what fascism means, a definition is in order. We have one straight from the horse’s mouth. As Benito Mussolini put it: “All within the state, nothing outside the state, nothing against the state.” Fascism is a doctrine of total state control. It is also, as Mussolini and Giovanni Gentile made clear, a subset of socialism. The fascists did not invent the idea of the state swallowing the economy: they borrowed it from the socialists, restricted it to the nation-state and its citizens and put it in a snappier uniform.

Yet Weber, in the name of “anti-fascist economics”, wants pretty much all of that bar the natty uniforms – socialised state control over the essentials of life. Housing, food, energy, water, health care, transport: all to be made affordable by the state, with affordability “safeguarded”. Today, she says, we are once again in a deep crisis of democracy. The extreme right is on the rise, she says, conveniently ignoring the ubiquity of the extreme left.

“It’s funny that today we think of anti-fascist economics as provocative,” she told the ABC. “In the 1940s it was actually a mainstream point for economists to say that economics had a role to play in ‘Never Again’.”

But, like Antifa, who ape the fascists by wearing black shirts and using street violence to impose their will, Weber’s “anti-fascist economics” are very, very fascist indeed. The black shirts have been swapped for academic citations, but the instinct is the same: the state must control the essentials, because whoever controls the essentials controls the economy and society.

She shot to prominence in late 2021 with a Guardian (no!) op-ed arguing for ‘temporary’ strategic price controls during Covid lockdowns.

“The idea that targeted price controls as an emergency measure merit serious consideration was greeted as if I had recommended a pornography exhibition in the Vatican,” she writes.

Of course, everyone was wrong but her. Socialism will work this time!

Her proposed remedy is an economic policy playbook that addresses the essentials with short-run measures and then structural changes to how they are provisioned. ‘Anti-fascist economics’ will change that by securing the necessities at affordable prices. In other words, the state will decide, controlling the means of production and imposing a planned economy. Do any of the adults in the room remember what we call that?

All within the state. Nothing outside the state. Nothing against the state. The intelligentsia’s favourite buzzword is being used to sell the very thing it is supposed to oppose. Orwell would have recognised the trick immediately.

The public square is still being poisoned by people who refuse to examine the words they are so fond of repeating.


💡
If you enjoyed this article please share it using the share buttons at the top or bottom of the article.

Latest

Good Oil Backchat

Good Oil Backchat

Please read our rules before you start commenting on The Good Oil to avoid a temporary or permanent ban.

Members Public