Skip to content

Experts Gang Up on the Voters

It’s not that the system failed. It’s that the voters did. Do they even hear themselves talk?

Photo by Dmitrii Vaccinium / Unsplash

Rodney Hide
Rodney Hide is a former minister and ACT Party leader.

Here’s a tip. Always be alarmed when experts gang up to sign a letter telling us what to do. If they had a good argument, one author would be enough.

This week 46 of them signed an open letter titled “Keep the ‘P’ in MMP”. It’s addressed to the new parliament. And experts? Give me a break.

It turns out that when the common people voted, they didn’t vote the way they should have. That’s funny. I thought democracy was about people voting as they choose, not as experts think they should.

The letter complains of “a breakdown, both accidental and deliberately engineered, in the purpose of the party and electorate votes”. The purpose? Says who? Voters get two ticks, and they have every right to use them as they see fit. Many gave their party vote to one party and their electorate vote to the local candidate they reckoned would do the best job, or the one most likely to beat the candidate they least wanted. That isn’t a breakdown. That’s people thinking.

The experts don’t like it. They say “a sincere vote” should be worth more than “an insincere tactical vote”. So now our votes are to be marked for sincerity. Who does the marking? The professors, of course.

They worry some voters found all the talk of split voting “confusing”. The voters seemed to manage fine. It’s the experts who are confused. For 30 years we’ve been told MMP is the fairest system going. Then voters used it in a way they didn’t expect, and now it urgently needs fixing.

The 1986 Royal Commission said deliberate manipulation would be “difficult to implement and likely to attract an electoral backlash”. The letter says that in 2026 overhangs “were not difficult to engineer”. Engineer? Nothing was engineered. Voters were persuaded, which is what election campaigns are for.

The fixes on offer are a sight to behold. Take electorate seats off the people who won them (the locals chose you, but tough, you’re out). Cut the number of electorates. (I note none of the experts have been an MP.) Merge the two votes into one, so we lose the choice altogether. Or let MPs keep their seats but count their votes in the House at a discount. That’s it, two classes of MP. Imagine doing that to the Māori Party.

Every option comes down to the same thing: if voters won’t vote the way the experts want, change the rules until the result comes out right.

And the timing is no accident. The letter wants a select committee to report by mid-2027 so the law can be changed “well before the next general election”. In other words, before voters get another go.

Be clear what the experts are saying. It’s not that the system failed. It’s that the voters did.

Do they even hear themselves talk?

This article was originally published by Brash and Mitchell.

Latest

Vic Labor Is Facing a Landslide Defeat

Vic Labor Is Facing a Landslide Defeat

While I’ll be supporting the Libertarian Party in my heart, in my head I’m looking forward to seeing a record result for One Nation and witnessing the biggest demolition of the Victorian Labor party for decades.

Members Public
Get Used to More Like 2026

Get Used to More Like 2026

You are given two votes. You can use them how you like. To vote in such a way so as to engineer the outcome you want is not manipulating the system.

Members Public