Despite both sides of the political divide seemingly unhappy with the election outcome, to those of us who actually understand MMP, more so than the politicians and some dyed in the wool voters it would seem, this was a true, probably the first true, MMP election. Some of us have been so-called ‘rigging the system’ since the first opportunity presented itself in the 1996 election. We have been doing this for 30 years now. Not a peep out of anyone. Why not? Because the elections always turned up a result resembling First Past the Post.
If that is the type of outcome the majority wanted and are happy with, why then did we vote to change to MMP. What was the point? The point was to stop major parties ruling the roost and determining on their own the direction of the country. It was supposed to give smaller parties a better chance of entering parliament thereby introducing more diversity and ideas. On that point there was a risk of the tail wagging the dog. That hasn’t happened but this election has produced a result which is risking it more than any other. I’m talking about Opportunity. It still won’t happen because, thanks to the split-voting strategy, on election night figures Opportunity is not the kingmaker.
Seymour chasing the finance role is probably the closest we’ll come to a minor party playing a major role. Personally, I think he’d do well in the job but the extent to which he would slash and burn would be too much for Luxon to contemplate. Which brings us right back to the problems voters have with National. Too timid and too Labour lite. This is a prime example of why National only secured 29 per cent of the party vote. National needs to understand that at an election the voters are in charge, not them. If you don’t do what your voters want you are in trouble.
Labour needs to understand that as well; that includes most on the left, both the politicians and the so-called expert commentators. Like National, they are in denial and refusing to accept this is how MMP, under its current rules, is supposed to work. Luxon, of course, deliberately called for two ticks blue, even when that meant the equivalent of a scaling of Everest proportions was required to win. Both he and Key hammered the point – ‘If you want a strong National Party Government then party vote National.’ Luxon wanted it so he could continue his ‘my or the highway’ style of leadership. Unfortunately for him many on the right did not want that. Another failure to read the room.
It didn’t take long for the whingers to come out of the woodwork. Chris Hipkins said, “National was still in the hunt only because it had manipulated the system.” This schoolboy analogy beggars belief. The little lad thinks National screaming “two ticks blue” is a manipulation of the system. That’s an NCEA level one fail.
Helen Clark, like John Key (poking her nose in where it wasn’t wanted), said it was a flawed election. The only flaw I noticed was that, knowing what was at risk, more National voters didn’t use their noodle and party vote elsewhere to ensure an uncontested result. Bryce Edwards’ claim is the result didn’t reflect proportionality and, depending on how you look at it, he has a point. He says there’s a loophole in MMP that can be taken advantage of. Chlöe Swarbrick, proving a leopard doesn’t change its spots, called it “mask-off voter suppression” which, courtesy of the Māori Party (the first to implement it), gave the Greens maybe two extra seats and their highest party vote ever.
But is the Māori Party at fault? No, no, no, according to Chlöe who is careful not to mention them. It’s all the fault of those nasty rich billionaires on the right gerrymandering the electoral system. I barely heard one lefty commentator mention the Māori Party. Tactical voting was all the fault of the right with people like Harry Mowbray and Maurice Williamson advising people how to, in their words, game the system. It’s all a load of bollocks. The system is what it is and voters can use it how they like. Lefties, with their knickers in a knot, are superfluous to the conversation.
There is an article on the Conversation titled ‘What really drove NZ’s election overhang and what can be done about it’. To the undoubted dismay of the lefty whiners and whingers what this article says is there is no one answer that will completely eliminate the tactical voting strategy. That means, in my view, it is here to stay and should be used where applicable, such as the election just gone, to ensure the left receive a political bloody nose every time. We don’t want them in power ever again and tactical voting is the means by which we achieve that.
If National doesn’t change course, and I can’t see it under Luxon, then the low party poll ratings will persist. Unless the party gets at least some of its conservative voters back, it will probably, at least under MMP, never have any list MPs again. Tactical voting will see to that. I’m sure, after seeing this result, many will have had a wake-up call as to what they could and should have done. To listen to some of the commentary you would have thought tactical voting was some form of a new phenomenon.
You are given two votes. You can use them how you like. To vote in such a way so as to engineer the outcome you want is not manipulating the system. IT IS YOUR DEMOCRATIC RIGHT. Nobody can force you to vote ‘two ticks blue’ or two ticks any other political colour. If in 2029 we find ourselves in the same position as 2026, then tactical voting is not an option: it is a must. It is the most effective method of keeping the left out of power. Permanently. This is why the schoolboy and his chums don’t want a bar of it. They see the danger and the possible electoral extermination of an entire political movement.
Get used to more like 2026! I’ll drink to that and you should too. Think about it. New Zealand would have the world’s first democratically elected dictatorship. Always the same winner and always democratically elected. What could be better. CHEERS TO THAT!