Skip to content

Who Decides How Taxpayers’ Money Is Spent?

The courts are entitled to determine whether legislation is consistent with the Bill of Rights. They are not entitled to dictate parliament’s spending priorities.

Photo by Sasun Bughdaryan / Unsplash

Richard Prebble
Columnist, former cabinet minister and ACT Party leader.

Mr Justice Paul Radich has ruled that the government’s 2025 amendments to the Equal Pay Act were principally motivated by fiscal considerations.

“The documents, viewed as a whole, show that the main driver was fiscal.”

But determining fiscal priorities is parliament’s responsibility, not the courts.

Under our constitution, parliament authorises taxation and public expenditure. It is parliament that determines fiscal priorities.

A government that failed to consider the fiscal consequences of legislation would be failing in its duties.

The courts are entitled to determine whether legislation is consistent with the Bill of Rights. They are not entitled to dictate parliament’s spending priorities.

My advice to the incoming government is to acknowledge the judgment and fulfil its legal obligations.

The government should then declare that it is parliament’s role, not the courts to determine fiscal priorities.

The government will not be paying social workers as if they were air traffic controllers because it is not fiscally responsible.

The government will uphold the Bill of Rights by ensuring that women can become air traffic controllers.

This article was originally published by I’ve Been Thinking.

Latest