Skip to content

MMP

Has National Won?

Has National Won?

Penk says National’s leadership was right not to endorse vote-splitting but went too far insulting the voters who did it. The leadership was dead wrong. On the preliminary count National has lost the party vote, and the same people who lectured Winston Peters in 2017 now need him to choose them.

Members Public
The Losers Want New Rules

The Losers Want New Rules

Nine days after the vote, former MPs want an unelected Future Generations commissioner no minister can direct and MMP’s academic defenders want a rewrite, because an 11-seat overhang arrived at scale. The official result is still not in.

Members Public
Cartoon: a giant Winston Peters looms over a TV studio boxing ring holding a bell and a scorecard while tiny Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins square off below.

Neither Chris Gets to Decide

Winston Peters says Luxon and Hipkins will not decide this election and the media is still running it like first past the post. Two more Chris-on-Chris debates are booked. The kingmaker is the story nobody is billing.

Members Public
Cartoon: Qiulae Wong eagerly dials a phone while Christopher Luxon hides behind a memo reading Ruled Out and peeks sideways at a ringing red phone marked Q.

Luxon Will Pick Up the Phone

Luxon has ruled out Opportunity, but he never said he wouldn’t take the call. On current polling the overhang strategy is the only way to keep Opportunity out and the coalition in.

Members Public
Cartoon: Winston Peters carries Christopher Luxon and David Seymour up a hill toward a sign reading 65, while Nicola Willis follows behind wagging a finger.

Winston Brought the Majority

NZ First is up to 12 per cent and 16 seats and that is what puts the coalition on 65. National’s party vote still buys no list MP. Electorate vote National, party vote ACT or NZ First.

Members Public
Cartoon: Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins stand glum at a National List Lift marked Out of Order while anonymous figures scramble through an Overhang door.

Three Polls Say Split Your Vote

Tuesday’s three polls all show the majors bleeding to the minors. Neither Chris is liked. National’s list lift is a forlorn hope. Electorate National or best candidate; party vote ACT or NZ First.

Members Public
Cartoon: Chris Hipkins brands Split Your Vote an absolute rort on one side while leaving a Te Pati Maori pathway open on the other

Hipkins the Hypocrite

Hipkins called Harry Mowbray’s split-vote campaign an absolute rort by wealthy entrenched interests. Under MMP an overhang is a feature, not a loophole. Chippy only hates it when his mates aren’t running it. If it is absolute fraud, rule Te Pāti Māori out. He will not.

Members Public